Journal / 02

The role of a room comes before its style

How I Think About a Home

Lakeside living space · portfolio design study used here as editorial context; the observations concern the design process more broadly.
Lakeside living space · portfolio design study used here as editorial context; the observations concern the design process more broadly.

The first question I ask about a room is not always what it should look like. I want to know what it is supposed to contribute to the household—and what the rest of the home already provides.

During a home visit, people sometimes apologize for toys, pets, stacks of paper or the condition of a favorite chair. I don't treat those moments as faults. They can be useful openings into a conversation about how someone actually lives. A room that requires constant protection or rearranging may be doing less for its occupants than it ought to.

Those apologies are often worth listening to more carefully than a polished description of someone's style. One person worries about a dog climbing onto the sofa. Another is embarrassed about a stack of papers or the lack of a rug in a high-traffic area. I notice those details, but I don't assume I understand them immediately. Someone may apologize out of habit or politeness. The observation becomes useful only when it opens an honest conversation about how the home is being used.

The composition of the household is not an adequate design brief. Saying that a family has children or pets doesn't reveal where they spend their time, how the children behave at different ages, or what a particular animal actually does. A dog that likes sitting on the back cushions to watch the street raises a different concern from one that scratches a surface. Materials, construction, access and maintenance follow from real behavior, not simply from a category such as 'pet-friendly.'

Nor do I assume that every room has to be designed to withstand every activity. Someone can want a space with refined furnishings expected to last fifteen or twenty years and still live with young children. The household may establish certain expectations about how that particular room is used. Other rooms can provide more freedom for play and informal activity. That is not a contradiction. It is one way of acknowledging that different parts of life ask different things of their surroundings.

This is why I often begin by thinking about the entire home rather than the room directly in front of us. Furniture suitable for a child's more active activities may already exist, but be located in a space the adults hope to keep more formal. Sometimes reorganizing what belongs where is more productive than buying an entirely new set of pieces. The room's purpose becomes clearer as we consider the roles already fulfilled elsewhere—and the roles that have been neglected.

Phasing matters for the same reason. A design can be coherent without every element arriving on the same day. If a toddler is in a period when accidents are especially likely, or the family has just brought home a puppy, choosing the permanent luxury rug later may preserve the intended design better than buying the wrong material today. We can specify the direction now and make investments at times that suit the household.

I often see people make rooms more and more alike because the same activities are allowed to spread everywhere. Eventually the distinctions disappear, even though the house has multiple rooms. An integrated life does not require every activity to coexist in one room. It can mean being able to move among environments that give genuinely different aspects of life room to happen.

I don't want a room to ask people to become a fictional, tidier or more formal version of themselves before they can enjoy it. Equally, I don't think good design means accepting every behavior everywhere without question. The work lies in understanding the life people genuinely want to lead, including their habits, responsibilities, aspirations and boundaries, then making the house support that life rather than continually interrupt it.

I also look across the entire home. When every space gradually takes on the same responsibilities, the household may lose opportunities for other kinds of experiences. A lively family room and a more refined retreat can coexist. So can a place for work and a place where no work is expected. Integration does not require every activity to occupy every room.

Timing matters as much as placement. With very young children or a new puppy, an investment rug might be the right long-term choice but the wrong immediate purchase. We can develop the room's direction, make appropriate changes now and complete other pieces later.

My aim is not to design for an imagined future version of the client. It is to understand the life already being lived, make room for what is missing and allow the design to grow with the people who inhabit it.

← Back to the journalNext article: Subtlety Is Touched Up Close →